Coney Island, a beloved symbol of American leisure and history, recently faced a significant threat: a massive casino, hotel, and convention center project known as “The Coney.” Proposed by billionaire developer Joe Sitt and his consortium (Thor Equities, Saratoga Casino Holdings, Global Gaming Solutions, and Legends Hospitality), this $3 billion to $3.4 billion development aimed to transform the iconic amusement area. However, thanks to a powerful community uproar, the project has been canceled, preserving the unique character and historical significance of Coney Island.
The Stakes: What Was at Risk?
“The Coney” project posed a severe threat to the heart and soul of Coney Island. Key concerns included:
- Loss of Amusement Rides: Nearly half of the existing rides were slated for removal, with others at risk, potentially leaving only the Wonder Wheel and the Cyclone.
- Threat to Coney Island USA and the Mermaid Parade: The non-profit arts organization, Coney Island USA, which sponsors the iconic Mermaid Parade, faced an uncertain future, jeopardizing one of New York’s most beloved events.
- Traffic and Community Disruption: The project involved closing W 12th St, Stillwell Ave, and W 15th to regular traffic, a move that Charles Denson of the Coney Island History Project highlighted as dangerous in his film.
- Change in Neighborhood Character: Many residents and activists feared the casino would drastically alter the unique character of Coney Island, replacing its vibrant, accessible charm with a corporate, high-stakes environment.
The Uproar and the Outcome
The community’s response was swift and passionate. Residents, activists, and local leaders rallied against the project, demonstrating the power of collective action. This grassroots movement involved:
- Public Hearings and Advocacy: Citizens actively participated in hearings and contacted politicians to voice their opposition.
- Petitions and Social Media: An online petition garnered over 12,500 signatures, and social media campaigns spread awareness and galvanized support.
- Community Advisory Committee (CAC) Engagement: The CAC played a crucial role, with public comments submitted via email to TheConeyPublicComment@nystec.com.
The culmination of these efforts came on September 29, 2025, when the Community Advisory Committee voted on the fate of “The Coney.” With four “NO” votes (Senator Jessica Scarcella-Spanton, Assemblymember Alec Brook-Krasny’s appointee Marissa Solomon, Borough President Antonio Reynoso, and Councilmember Justin Brannan), the project was killed, preventing it from moving forward to the Gaming Facility Location Board. This victory was a testament to the community’s unwavering dedication.
Takeaways and Implications for American Culture
The cancellation of “The Coney” casino project offers several profound takeaways and has significant implications for American culture and the enduring story of Coney Island:
- The Power of Community: This fight unequivocally demonstrated that organized community action can successfully challenge powerful developers and protect local heritage. It’s a powerful reminder that local voices matter.
- Preserving Cultural Landmarks: Coney Island is more than just an amusement park; it’s a living piece of American history and popular culture. It represents accessible fun, innovation in entertainment, and a vibrant, diverse community. Its preservation ensures that future generations can experience this unique cultural touchstone.
- Local History and Identity: Coney Island’s history is rich with stories of immigration, entrepreneurship, and the evolution of American leisure. From its beginnings as a seaside resort to its heyday as the “Nickel Empire” and its subsequent revitalization, Coney Island has always adapted while retaining its distinctive spirit. The casino threatened to erase much of this local history and replace it with a generic entertainment complex. The community’s victory ensures that Coney Island’s authentic identity can continue to thrive.
- A Symbol of Resilience: Coney Island has faced numerous challenges throughout its history, from fires to economic downturns. Each time, it has shown remarkable resilience. This latest triumph against the casino project adds another chapter to its story as a place that, despite external pressures, remains true to its roots.
- Rethinking Development: This outcome encourages a critical look at urban development, emphasizing the importance of projects that are in harmony with existing communities and cultural landscapes, rather than those that seek to override them for profit.
What’s Next for Coney Island?
With the casino project off the table, the community is now looking forward to discussions about what Coney Island truly wants for its neighborhood. Councilmember Justin Brannan has already reached out to community leaders to address issues such as cleaning up neglected, rat-infested lots owned by Joe Sitt’s Thor Equities.
This is a moment to celebrate the power of community and to continue advocating for a Coney Island that reflects its rich history and vibrant future. Stay informed by following @noconeycasino and @coney.island.usa on Instagram for updates.
The fight for Coney Island also highlights broader struggles. We encourage you to support friends at Voices of the Waterfront, who are seeking transparency in the Brooklyn Marine Terminal project. Learn more about their efforts and sign their petition here.
Source list:
- Coneyologist Substack – The Coney Casino Greed Kills
- NYC Council – Find Your District
- NYC Planning Zoning Application Portal – Project 2024K0230
- New York State Gaming Commission – Coney Community Advisory Committee
- YouTube – Coney Island Casino Funeral Send Off
- Instagram – @noconeycasino
- Instagram – @coney.island.usa
- Voices of the Waterfront
